Here’s how to manage direct debits and cycle money to get current account perks.
From cashback to monthly rewards, there are all sorts of incentives and freebies you can get with multiple current accounts. And don’t forget bank switching bonuses.
Plus there are benefits in terms of security and budgeting (read more about these in my why you should have more than one account article).
But the more accounts you have, the more admin is required. Plus many account switches and perks require extras like direct debits or minimum deposits each month.
All this can put some people off. But it’s actually a lot easier to manage than you’d imagine, and I think the reward is well worth the effort.
Regular readers will know I have 15 different current accounts at the moment so I’ve got to have processes in place to make sure I don’t accidentally go overdrawn on one or miss out on a perk on another.
Though it’s unlikely you’ll have this many accounts, the things I do will still work for you.
And the good news is that the admin can be done on one go early on, and then looks after itself!
Watch this video or keep reading (or both) for how I do it
Managing direct debits
Quite a few switching offers and perks require a couple of direct debits each month. Often it’ll say “active” direct debits, which technically could include any payment that has been taken in the last year.
But for the most part these direct debits have to come out every month to qualify – ruling out annual or quarterly payments.
I think you’ll need between eight and 12 ongoing direct debits to take full advantage of the offers. Though you can switch them from an old account it’s probably easier to manually set up new direct debits with the service provider if you’re moving money to different accounts.
And if you run out of the obvious direct debits, there are a few easy ones you can set up which won’t cost you anything.
You won’t need all of these accounts, but just to give you the full idea, here are the account perks and switches that require direct debits.
Switching bonuses that require direct debits
A decent number of banks offer free cash or rewards for moving your old account over to them as part of a switch. Though the terms and conditions vary, you might be required to move over some direct debits from this old account or set them up on the new account.
In most cases, these direct debits can be cancelled once you’ve got your cash bonus. So these are the accounts where you’ll probably want to add temporary or extra direct debits rather than move regular ones.
Switching offers come and go, but right now these are the accounts that require them:
- HSBC Advance – 2 direct debits or standing orders (can be added after the switch)
- Nationwide – 2 direct debits (active before you switch)
- Virgin Money M Plus – 2 direct debits (can be added after the switch)
It’s worth pointing out that the HSBC switch (when it runs) accepts standing orders as well as direct debits. This is a regular payment between accounts and really easy to set up to another current or savings account you hold. This makes it a better option than a direct debit.
Account rewards that require direct debits
The bulk of your direct debits are going to be needed for rewards. These are ongoing benefits that require a direct debit to be paid every month. If the payment doesn’t leave your account then you will miss out on the free money.
Account rewards that require the direct debits are:
- Barclays Blue Rewards – 2 direct debits (for monthly reward)
- Co-op Bank Everyday Rewards – 4 direct debits (for monthly reward)
- Natwest Reward – 2 direct debits of at least £2 (for monthly reward)
- RBS Reward – 2 direct debits of at least £2 (for monthly reward)
- Santander 123 Lite – 2 direct debits, though most likely five or six (for monthly cashback)
Personally I wouldn’t bother with the Co-op account as you don’t get much in return. So that’s eight direct debits you don’t need to worry about.
But if you then go for all the other four accounts you’d need at least eight direct debits and probably 11 or 12. This might seem a lot but it is possible.
Interest rates that require direct debits
These two accounts each require two direct debits if you want to earn 0.6% interest on savings of up to £3,999 and 1.5% on the balance between £4,000 and £5,000.
- Bank of Scotland Vantage – 2 direct debits (for interest)
- Club Lloyds – 2 direct debits (for interest)
It’s a decent rate compared to other options, but it can be beaten by better savings accounts. In light of that, I wouldn’t waste direct debits on these accounts.
Andy’s Top 3 Current Account perks
- £5 a month from the Halifax Rewards account
- 2.02% interest from Virgin Money’s M Plus Account
- £250 interest free buffer from First Direct
(You can learn more about the account perks and requirements on my huge list of current accounts.)
Managing the minimum transfers
Most of the accounts require me to pay money in every month. If I didn’t I could miss out on all those little bonuses or get charged a monthly fee.
Here are the minimums for the main current account perks:
- Barclays Blue Rewards – £800 a month (to get rewards)
- Bank of Scotland Vantage – £1,000 a month (to get interest)
- Co-op Bank Everyday Rewards -£800 a month
- Halifax Rewards – £1,500 a month (to avoid fee)
- HSBC Advance – £1,750 a month (to keep account)
- Club Lloyds – £1,500 a month (to avoid fee)
- Natwest Reward – £1,250 a month (to get keep account)
- Nationwide FlexDirect – £1,000 a month (for interest)
- RBS Reward – £1,250 a month (to get keep account)
- Santander 123 Lite – £500 a month (to get cashback)
So how do you make meeting this easier? Automation is the key here, with standing orders moving the money on the same day each month. You can set these up easily in your online or app banking (though not all apps let you amend them if you want to make changes).
If you do have multiple accounts with the same provider, transferring between them often doesn’t qualify (eg Halifax to Halifax), so you’ll need to factor this in.
There are three methods here:
The endless cycle
One trick is to move the same cash from account to account so it cycles through each one and back to the start, then repeats itself the next month and so on.
For example, you’ve got £1,000 in account a, which you transfer to account b, then to account c, then account d and finally back to account a. Then it repeats the next month, and so on.
The back and forth
Another option is to set up a standing order out of one account into another, and then back the next day. And then move the money into another account and back.
So you’re move £1,000 from account a to account b, then back to account a. Then move £1,000 from account a to account c, then back to account a. And so on.
It makes sense to spread these out through the month so you’re still only moving the same amount of cash. to make sure there is cash in the account to leave it in the first place.
The bitesize transfer
If you don’t have £1,000 in your account to keep moving around, you can split the requirement into smaller chunks. So it could be two lots of £500, or four lots of £250. You get the idea.
You can use either the endless cycle or back and forth methods to automate this – you’ll just have more standing orders in action.
Covering account fees & direct debits
Don’t forget to add into your transfers enough to cover any direct debits going out of the accounts and any fees you might be charged.
Here are the main accounts that have a fee:
- Barclays Blue Rewards – £4
- Co-op Bank Everyday Rewards – £2
- Halifax Rewards – £3 (avoid if you pay in £1,500 a month)
- Club Lloyds – £3 (avoid if you pay in £1,500 a month)
- Natwest Reward – £2
- RBS Reward – £2
- Santander 123 Lite – £2
Get the best of Andy’s money saving content every Thursday, straight to your inbox
+ Get a £17 Quidco bonus (new members only). More details
Collect your rewards
You should also factor in the rewards you’ll earn, but not all will pay directly into your account. You sometimes need to cash out your payments, so it’s worth making a note to do this once a month for the following:
- Barclays Blue Rewards (can be done via Barclays app)
- Natwest Reward (You need to log into the MyRewards site)
- RBS Reward (You need to log into the MyRewards site)
Logging into the app
There’s one final ongoing requirement with some accounts – you might need to log in to your online banking or app on a regular basis.
This might not be something you do naturally with extra accounts, so just put a note in the diary to do this once a month. It’ll take you two minutes.
- Co-Op Bank Rewards – every month
- Natwest Reward – every month
- RBS Reward- every month
- Santander 123 Lite – every three months
Making sure everything is OK
The standing orders and direct debits should all take care of themselves, but it’s worth making note of what money is going where and when. I’ve set up two spreadsheets to keep an eye on things.
The first tells me all the standing orders and direct debits in and out of each account. If I need to amend the size of a standing order (for example when switching banks), I know exactly which is which. It only updates if I change bank.
The other spreadsheet is more active. Every month I open up the apps for my accounts and write down the balances. I try to do this in the first week of the month. This way I know exactly how much I have in each account, and overall. I also add in how much I owe on each credit cards (even though I pay them off in full every month) so I get the true figure of my current savings.
I tend to use the banks’ own apps though services like Yolt and Money Dashboard can do this too. You can add all your accounts to it and see them all on one screen.
18 thoughts on “How I manage my multiple bank accounts”
I have 10k to invest where would you advise me to put it? I already have a fixed 1 year with 5k with Lloyd and a 250monthly regular saver, plus 2easy savers of 50 monthly.
I also have. RBS savings account with 15k but want to invest 10k of this and keep 5k just in case I need to get quick access
Do you think I need to see a financial advisor?
Thank you for your time
Some Switches require you to pay in a certain amount each month. Does this mean I can just pay the money in and then immediately take it out and repeat for each month?
Yes! Unless it specifically says the money needs to stay in the account until you get the bonus (eg with Virgin Money) then you can just withdraw it straight away.
Thank you for this post!
It is very reassuring as I have a few current accounts and linked “member exclusive” saving accounts & have done for years…I must say I’m having trouble seeing what’s what though..
I was wondering if you happened to have a template of your spreadsheets you use to keep track. I have a Money Dashboard account but it doesn’t have every account available – especially savings accounts.
Thank you for imparting your knowledge and your time Andy, you are clear in how you explain so complex stuff!! Thank you!
Hi Hannah. Yes, it can be a pain, and a real frustration that not all accounts (particularly some credit cards) aren’t available via those aggregator apps.
The spreadsheet is really simple so it won’t take long for you to create one in Google Sheets. It’s simply the name of the account and the balance. Then I have a total for the current accounts, a total for savings and a total (owed) for credit cards, with an overall balance total too.
At the end of the month I spend five minutes updating all the balances just to keep an eye on where things are!
I use Paypal to satisfy the 2 Direct debits on my Barclays account to get the monthly Blue reward bonus. Me and my wife both have Paypal accounts, so first I send £1 to her (using the pay a friend option) and make sure it is set up to come from my Barclays account. Then she withdraws the £1 and then sends me a £1 using the same technique, which then comes from my Barclays account. I then withdraw the £1 from my Paypal account.
Please can you tell us how much you make from each ac by doing this?
Hey Andy. I have a ‘good’ credit score. How impactful on my credit score would it be in general terms to open another current account needing a hard credit search? And the impact of another account showing as recently opened? I wouldn’t want my score which I’ve worked hard at improving to significantly drop again. Thanks
What about the dates of the transfer, for example, you set up the transfer for the 1st of the month, but it’s a Saturday, then say the Monday following is a bank holiday, how would you plan for this? Just worried that the I may not have the right amount in the account. The reason I ask is that I need that amount back in my main account as quickly as possible, hope you follow my train of thought there.
Yes, this can be an issue. I tend to leave a few days to allow for weekends (and bank holidays!). Remember, you don’t always have to move the money in one go. Say it’s £750 to transfer, you could move £250 there and back three times, do there’s less chance of you not having what you need in the account
Wow, you do well to keep on top of them all! Do they all have internet banking?
Yes, all online and have apps – though the M&S app is pointless!
Car lnsurancce via NFU, a Which? Best Buy, is available at 0% by DD. M&S Home lnurance also available at 0 %. Some separate Electric & Gas offers can be less expensive. l use a carousel system to qualify. Money leaves & usually returns same day. Anyone know a better deal than Santander 123 on Utilities, General & Water Rates cashbacks? They offer cb on their own products too, all covering the £24 annual fee suiting my circumstances. Can pay in cheques at P Offices – some open all day Sats & part Suns.
I would never have thought of paying money to an account and back like that!
Yeah it just does it all itself. Though it can mean there are a few days where you might think you have less than you actually do!